We’ve got a vineyard.
When we make a wine label change that requires a new approval, we are required to submit it to the federal bureaucracy at the TTB (the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau). We are like children seeking permission from our parents. The changes have to be reported, submitted, tracked, and approved.
It’s Prohibition-era leftover crap. Congress has never bothered to get rid of these archaic laws. No one adversely affected by these rules dares to question the overlords, because any bureaucrat with an attitude can shut down your winery in a millisecond. And no one else on the planet cares that I waste hours of my life filling out forms to assuage tax collectors and long-dead prohibitionists.
We are told by someone that it has to be done. So we do it. You do it. I do it. We are good sheep.
Meanwhile, a college will happily sell an eighteen-year-old $240,000 of federally-guaranteed debt for a degree in Liberal Studies with less regulatory paperwork than I have to provide for a label change.
It is time to close this horrific gap in the regulatory state, which is clearly an oversight in oversight. So I propose we demand a new boondoggle: the Federal Diploma Efficacy Administration — the FDEA — a cabinet-level agency tasked with subjecting every college degree to the evidentiary standard that the TTB demands for a sticker that goes on a bottle. And let’s throw in some evaluation of creditworthiness too, given that billions are being thrown around.
Under FDEA rules (that I will make), I would insist that no institution could sell a taxpayer funded degree until it completed a randomized trial. Two cohorts: one that sits through four years of lectures on important material like post-modern gender theory, and one that is a placebo control group in which the members hold down jobs, produce value, read library books and engage in Socratic chats with AI for free. Endpoints will be measured in income, employment, parasitism, and how many can find Florida on a map. Degrees that don’t beat placebo get a warning:
“This credential has not been shown to outperform four years of doing literally anything else.”
And no taxpayer money will be provided to any of them.
The colleges and universities won’t like this agency. Not initially.
Federal student loans are the troughs the university feasts from. Cheap credit pours into the universities coffers as they raise tuition higher every year to absorb all that credit. The university gets paid up front to indoctrinate the impressionable minds, and then buy up all the property in the town with the spare cash.
The universities won’t like it if we eliminate the federal subsidies and let loan officers price risk the way underwriters priced risk before Washington started guaranteeing every dollar lent to every eighteen-year-old regardless of major, GPA, or the debtor’s odds of ever earning enough to service it.
Consider the underwriting standards this agency would be improving on. Under the current system (before my proposal here), the Direct Loan program made more than $85 billion in federal student loans to more than 6.7 million borrowers each year. For ordinary Direct Subsidized and Unsubsidized Loans, there is no adverse credit-history check (because that is apparently racist) and no underwriting of whether the degree is likely to generate enough income to repay the debt. The outstanding federal student loan portfolio now includes 42.6 million recipients with $1.7 trillion in federal student debt. More than 17.2 million recipients—about 42%—have at least one loan in a current repayment or delinquency status.
As of March 2026, 8.4 million recipients had at least one loan in forbearance, while approximately 9 million borrowers were in default, with $220 billion in outstanding federal student loans in default. If only these debtors were allowed to counterfeit the currency, they could print their way out of their debt. But counterfeiting the currency is illegal, isn’t it? (There’s probably a reason for that.)
The universities needn’t fret over this new agency. The FDEA would be immediately captured by the entities it’s supposed to police. The applications will be approved rapidly for new majors such as “Equity and Diversity in the Age of Colonization,” “American Popular Culture,” and “Safe Space Design” while majors that teach anything that is economically sound and morally sane will get blocked. The banks would be encouraged to fight racism by … you know … discriminating based on race: preferential rates for the currently popular oppressed group, regardless of an individual’s ability to pay it back.
Readers of this letter already know the real fix isn’t a new bureau, even a bureau that I design. The fix is to remove the cause of the problem: the federal subsidy and intervention structure that has allowed this market to misprice risk for decades. But that will not ever happen.
What will happen is that socialists will forgive the student loans the first chance they get—at once buying the youth vote, expanding their system of indoctrination, and doubling down on the insanity to come.
Keep your loved ones away from that insanity, or at least don’t contribute to it.
Doug, along with Matt Smith and his son Maxim, created The Preparation to help with that. I was there when the early seeds were planted. And I love the whole idea. It’s a system of education, not schooling. Check it out, and then join me in spreading the word, and maybe the next 18-year-old will skip the debt and skip the college and go on to be a moral, sound, productive adult.
We need more of those.
But as that is unlikely, maybe just douse your sorrow with our wine.
If we ever get our labels approved.
Sincerely,
John Hunt, MD
Editor, Doug Casey’s Crisis Investing



During covid in wonderful Vancouver Beautiful British Columbia a deli that had been in business for many years was shut down due to health inspections. But the the lovely German girl who I knew by first name had told me that a mask needed to be worn inside the store. She had informed prior that on the early days of insanity they were receiving blowback from the gestapo and if I could simply have a mask hanging around my neck only to raise it if someone entered the store. I got taste of what it must have been like in Nazi Germany to be on the lookout for informants.
Absolutely 100% correct. While the far-cat administrative and professorial elitist class live high on their Student’s debt, they indoctrinate those same students to blame everyone but themselves and the Institutional Ivy Towers of Higher debt for their uneducated mess.